44 questions, ranked.
Every question the Talkin' Baseball hosts asked on air that data could settle, grouped and ranked by how good a segment the answer would make, then by how often it came up.
Q-01Why do teams beat or miss their expected record?1 idea18×Answered
Planned studyDecompose wins minus BaseRuns/run-differential expectation into bullpen leverage, clutch hitting, one-run and head-to-head records, Retrosheet 1950-2026, versus league-average deviation and year-to-year persistence.
Asked on air, for example (paraphrased)How many one-run and two-run games have the Reds lost to the Brewers? Jake, Jun 26, 2026
Ideas that could answer itRead the answer- Real or RandomExperiment
Deal one-run game sequences from lucky and unlucky teams without names. The one-run study found that record is mostly coin flips; if players can't tell the good teams from the lucky ones, that's the same finding from the gut side.
- Real or RandomExperiment
Q-02How fast can you tell a breakout or decline is real?1 idea13×Up next
Planned studyRolling xwOBA, bat speed, chase and walk rates versus prior baseline for 2015-2026 breakouts and collapses; measure PA thresholds where change beats projection, against league regression rates.
Asked on air, for example (paraphrased)How did Ben Rice suddenly become one of the best hitters in baseball out of nowhere? Jake, Jun 3, 2026
Ideas that could answer it- Breakout ClockTool
Pick any hitter and stat. The clock compares his rolling numbers with his prior baseline and shows how many more plate appearances it takes before the change is bigger than the noise for that stat.
- Breakout ClockTool
Q-03How much of a one-season split or rate stat is just noise?1 idea10×Up next
Planned studyYear-to-year correlation and regression coefficients for platoon, home-road, day-night, RISP, half-season splits, LOB% and batter-vs-pitcher history, Retrosheet/Statcast 2000-2026, versus binomial-noise expectation.
Asked on air, for example (paraphrased)Would a hitter who's succeeded against a pitcher in a small sample eventually start struggling against him with more at-bats? Jake, Apr 8, 2026
Ideas that could answer it- Breakout ClockTool
The same math works for splits. Enter a day-night, home-road or versus-pitcher split and see whether the sample is big enough to mean anything yet.
- Breakout ClockTool
Q-04How reliable are defensive metrics, and do they agree?1 idea8×Up next
Planned studyYear-to-year correlation and cross-metric agreement of OAA, DRS and UZR by position, plus double-play conversion rates, Statcast 2016-2026, versus noise expectation and scout grades.
Asked on air, for example (paraphrased)Among the AL second base candidates (Clement, Jackson, McNeil, Young), who is performing better defensively? Trevor, May 6, 2026
Ideas that could answer it- Glove ConsensusVisualization
Plot every fielder's rating in one system against another. Points near the diagonal are fielders everyone agrees on; the far ones show exactly where and by how much the systems disagree.
- Glove ConsensusVisualization
Q-05Is a power outage the park, the luck, or the hitter?2 ideas8×Up next
Planned studyActual versus expected home runs from exit velocity, launch angle, spin and carry, re-simulated at all 30 parks, Statcast 2015-2026, versus league conversion rate.
Asked on air, for example (paraphrased)How much does a ballpark's dimensions/park factors actually affect a hitter's home run totals? Jake, Feb 16, 2026
Ideas that could answer it- Spray AtlasTool
Compare a hitter's pulled fly balls this year with past years. If the hard, pulled air contact is still there but stays in the park, look at the park; if it's gone, the hitter changed.
- Power AuditResearch
Split a hitter's home run change into three parts. Park is his expected home runs in a neutral park versus his own; luck is actual home runs versus what his contact deserved; hitter is the change in that contact itself.
- Spray AtlasTool
Q-06Do some organizations and coaches really improve the players they get?1 idea7×Queued
Planned studyBefore-and-after projected-versus-actual wRC+, stuff and pitch-mix change for players joining each club or coach, Statcast 2015-2026, versus matched controls and the 30-team average.
Asked on air, for example (paraphrased)How much credit for Luis Arraez's defensive improvement belongs to Ron Washington's infield coaching versus Arraez's own work? Jake, May 1, 2026
Ideas that could answer it- Player FactoryResearch
For every player who joins a new organization, compare what he did there with a projection made from his numbers before the move. Average the gap by organization to see which ones really add value, with error bars.
- Player FactoryResearch
Q-07Are injuries rising, and does workload explain it?1 idea7×Queued
Planned studyIL placements, IL days and WAR lost per team per season plus hamate incidence, injury data 2010-2026, versus base rates, correlated with bat speed and year-over-year innings jumps.
Asked on air, for example (paraphrased)Why are so many players (like Lindor, Carroll, Holliday) suffering hamate bone injuries this spring, and what are they doing differently to cause it? Trevor, Feb 11, 2026
Ideas that could answer it- Velo WatchTool
Mark injured-list stints on the same timeline to test whether velocity dips came before injuries, and whether heavy recent workloads came before the dips.
- Velo WatchTool
Q-08Are team hot and cold streaks more than coin-flip noise?2 ideas7×Answered
Planned studyDistribution of best and worst 30-to-60-game stretches by team, Retrosheet 1901-2026, versus Monte Carlo simulation from individual game logs and binomial expectation for equal-talent teams.
Asked on air, for example (paraphrased)Is it actually true that the Red Sox's 31-5 record over their last 36 games is the best 36-game record in MLB history? Trevor, Aug 7, 2026
Ideas that could answer itRead the answer- Claim CheckTool
The Red Sox's 31–5 is the prototype. Answers for Coach checked "best 36 games ever" and found six AL/NL teams with a better run, but no team that went 31–5 from that far below .500. Claim Check makes that a repeatable process.
- Real or RandomExperiment
Put team win-loss runs in the deck, including the 2026 Red Sox's 31–5. Answers for Coach found that run unlikely as pure luck; this asks whether people can see it, too.
- Claim CheckTool
Q-09Does lineup construction and depth change run scoring?1 idea7×Queued
Planned studyRuns per inning by leadoff lineup spot, on-deck hitter quality effects on walks and wOBA, fifth-through-ninth-best-hitter wRC+, and team output minus its best hitter, Retrosheet/Statcast 1990-2026, versus league average.
Asked on air, for example (paraphrased)Does it actually benefit a team for its nine-hole hitter to make the final out with two outs, so the leadoff hitter starts the next inning with the bases empty? Jake, Mar 18, 2026
Ideas that could answer it- Lineup LabInteractive
Drag hitters into any order and simulate thousands of games. The gap between the best and worst orders shows how much lineup construction really changes run scoring, with the noise drawn in so a small gap doesn't look like a big one.
- Lineup LabInteractive
Q-10Are high-leverage relievers worth more than their WAR says?1 idea6×Queued
Planned studyCompare closers' WAR to WPA and championship-added, and team win change when they are lost or replaced, Retrosheet/Statcast 2010-2026, versus WAR's prediction and hitter-value conversion.
Asked on air, for example (paraphrased)Has Cam Schlittler affected more plays/games this season than Jordan Alvarez has, factoring in how he impacts outcomes compared to a hitter? Jake, Sep 25, 2026
Ideas that could answer it- Leverage LedgerVisualization
Put each reliever's WAR next to his win probability added and a leverage-weighted value. The relievers whose bars disagree most are the ones WAR undersells or oversells.
- Leverage LedgerVisualization
Q-11Do hitter hot and cold streaks predict anything at all?1 idea6×Queued
Planned studyNext-15-PA wOBA, walk rate and pitch mix after 10-game hot streaks, slow starts, hitless runs and hit-by-pitches, Retrosheet/Statcast 2000-2026, versus each hitter's season baseline.
Asked on air, for example (paraphrased)Does getting hit by pitches help a hitter avoid falling into slumps? Jake, Sep 2, 2026
Ideas that could answer it- Real or RandomExperiment
Show a hitter's real game-by-game log next to copies rolled from his season averages. If players can't pick the real one more often than chance, his hot and cold stretches look like what randomness produces anyway.
- Real or RandomExperiment
Q-12How has the starter-reliever workload split actually evolved?1 idea6×Queued
Planned studyRelief share of innings, pitches and batters per start, piggyback outings, lefty-reliever share, pitchers used per team and consecutive-game reliever usage, Retrosheet 1950-2026, versus league trend.
Asked on air, for example (paraphrased)Which teams used to call up large numbers of players (like 40) in September before roster expansion rules changed? Jake, Aug 28, 2026
Ideas that could answer it- Leverage LedgerVisualization
Chart the share of innings thrown by starters and relievers every season, with the high-leverage innings highlighted, to show how the split evolved and where the important innings went.
- Leverage LedgerVisualization
Q-13How much has the ball and the home run era shifted?2 ideas6×Queued
Planned studyHome runs per batted ball, inferred drag, 20-homer and 55-homer season counts and run distribution, Retrosheet 1901-2026 plus Statcast, controlling for temperature, launch conditions and parks.
Asked on air, for example (paraphrased)How many 20-home-run seasons occur across MLB in a given year, on average per team? Trevor, Jul 24, 2026
Ideas that could answer it- Power AuditResearch
Run the same split league-wide by season to separate the ball, the parks and the hitters across the home run era.
- Era DialInteractive
Put home runs per game on the same dial so the home run era's peaks and dips line up against the rule changes and against strikeouts.
- Power AuditResearch
Q-14What drives in-season velocity swings, and does velocity come back?2 ideas6×Queued
Planned studyFastball velocity by count, inning, month and leverage for pitchers losing or gaining 2-plus mph, Statcast 2015-2026, versus age-based decline curves, rest patterns and acquiring-team effects.
Asked on air, for example (paraphrased)Would the Brewers ever consider skipping a start or shutting down Freddy Peralta/Misiorowski given his declining velocity, despite his Cy Young push? Trevor, Aug 28, 2026
Ideas that could answer it- Velo WatchTool
Plot every start's average fastball against the pitcher's own baseline band. Dips outside the band are flagged, and the chart shows how often velocity came back and how long it took.
- Tunnel VisionVisualization
Compare a pitcher's tunnels on high-velocity and low-velocity days. If the pairs split earlier when velocity is down, it shows what a velocity dip costs beyond the radar gun.
- Velo WatchTool
Q-15Do unusual arm angles and deliveries make pitchers better?2 ideas5×Queued
Planned studyRun value, platoon splits, swing-timing misses and survival by arm-angle bucket and tempo variance, Statcast 2020-2026, versus over-the-top, consistent-tempo pitchers and the league pitch-profile centroid.
Asked on air, for example (paraphrased)Why don't more pitchers drop down to a submarine/sidearm arm angle like Tyler Rogers, given his success? Jake, Dec 15, 2025
Ideas that could answer it- Tunnel VisionVisualization
Measure how long each pitcher's pairs stay together, grouped by arm slot. If unusual slots keep pitches tunneled longer, that's a mechanism for why they work, not just a correlation.
- Read the PitchExperiment
Log every clip's arm angle and release point. If players misread pitches from low or unusual slots more often, that's direct evidence the delivery itself hides the ball, which is the case the hosts keep making for funky arm angles.
- Tunnel VisionVisualization
Q-16How much is catcher receiving worth, and will ABS erase it?1 idea5×Queued
Planned studyCalled-strike probability by location and count, catcher-specific framing runs, and before-after ABS change, Statcast MLB 2015-2026 plus Triple-A 2022-2025, versus the league-average receiver.
Asked on air, for example (paraphrased)How will the ABS (automated strike zone) system affect catcher framing metrics and defensive ratings? Trevor, Mar 18, 2026
Ideas that could answer it- Zone ShiftResearch
Measure each catcher's framing runs before and after challenges arrived. If the best framers lose the most, ABS is erasing the skill; if the ranking holds, framing still pays on the calls nobody challenges.
- Zone ShiftResearch
Q-17What do bat-tracking metrics reveal about swings and hidden power?1 idea5×Queued
Planned studyBat speed by count, swing length, attack angle, finish height and spray angle versus exit velocity and ISO, Statcast 2023-2026, against hitters matched on size and output.
Asked on air, for example (paraphrased)How many hitters actually finish their swing with the bat below shoulder height, like Manzardo does? Trevor, May 4, 2026
Ideas that could answer it- Spray AtlasTool
Color batted balls by bat speed and squared-up rate to find hitters whose fastest swings land in the wrong part of the field, the hidden power the hosts keep wondering about.
- Spray AtlasTool
Q-18Do pitchers throw their best pitches in the right spots?2 ideas4×Queued
Planned studyRun value per 100 and whiff rate by pitch type, count and location versus usage share, Statcast 2008-2026, including first pitches and known hitter weaknesses, against league sequencing baselines.
Asked on air, for example (paraphrased)How much would Ben Rice's vulnerability to high velocity actually factor into opposing teams' scouting reports and pitch-calling strategy? Jake, Aug 19, 2026
Ideas that could answer it- Tunnel VisionVisualization
Draw where each pitch finishes against where its tunnel partner does. A pitcher locating well keeps pairs tight until late and splits them toward the edges, not the middle.
- Read the PitchExperiment
Score each call against the pitch's location as well as its type. A pitcher whose best pitch is hardest to read when it's on the edge is throwing it in the right spot.
- Tunnel VisionVisualization
Q-19Does WAR value defense and positions correctly?1 idea4×Queued
Planned studySpread of defensive runs by position, sprint-speed-to-OAA correlation, and WAR change for position switches, Statcast 2015-2026, versus WAR's positional adjustments and equal-WAR bat-first players.
Asked on air, for example (paraphrased)What do advanced defensive metrics say about which positions matter most defensively? guest, Jun 3, 2026
Ideas that could answer it- Glove ConsensusVisualization
Show how much of each player's WAR comes from defense and the position adjustment, and how far his WAR would move if a different defensive system were plugged in.
- Glove ConsensusVisualization
Q-20How well do international stars translate to MLB?1 idea4×Queued
Planned studyMLB wRC+, WAR and All-Star rates for NPB/KBO signings and by birth country per capita, 1995-2026, versus preseason projections, comparable domestic free agents and signing destinations.
Asked on air, for example (paraphrased)Have most Japanese players who came over to MLB historically ended up signing with West Coast teams? Trevor, Nov 10, 2025
Ideas that could answer it- Player FactoryResearch
Apply it to players arriving from Japan and Korea, comparing their first MLB seasons with what their previous league's numbers translated to.
- Player FactoryResearch
Q-21What actually makes a successful base stealer?1 idea4×Queued
Planned studyVariance in steal success explained by sprint speed versus jump, lead and disengagement count, Statcast 2015-2026, plus team baserunning runs and whether technique markers transfer year to year.
Asked on air, for example (paraphrased)Why don't pitchers/catchers attempt a third pickoff throw after two unsuccessful pickoff attempts, given how big a lead the runner takes afterward? Trevor, Jul 3, 2026
Ideas that could answer it- Steal LabResearch
Split every steal attempt into the runner's lead, jump and sprint speed against the pitcher's time to the plate and the catcher's pop time, and measure how much each piece moves the odds of being safe.
- Steal LabResearch
Q-22Do power, speed and pitching skills age on different curves?1 idea3×Queued
Planned studyAge-27-to-37 WAR, wRC+, stuff and command trajectories for power-first, speed-first hitters and elite starters, 1950-2026, versus the overall league aging curve.
Asked on air, for example (paraphrased)Do power hitters tend to age better than speed-reliant players, as some stats suggest? Trevor, Dec 10, 2025
Ideas that could answer it- Prime TimeVisualization
Build separate aging curves for sprint speed, power, plate discipline and pitch velocity from year-to-year changes in the same players, and show where each skill peaks and how fast it fades.
- Prime TimeVisualization
Q-23Does payroll buy wins, and would a cap change parity?1 idea3×Queued
Planned studyTeam revenue, deferral-adjusted payroll and WAR per dollar versus wins, 2000-2026; payroll bunching at the CBT line; win-percentage spread and title concentration versus capped leagues.
Asked on air, for example (paraphrased)How does having a salary cap compare to baseball in creating competitive parity in other sports? Trevor, Oct 18, 2025
Ideas that could answer it- Division GapResearch
Plot payroll against wins every season and measure how tight the link is, then show how the spread of team quality would change if payrolls were squeezed together.
- Division GapResearch
Q-24Which recent rule changes measurably changed the game?2 ideas3×Queued
Planned studyPitching changes, game time, pace, walk rate and violation counts before and after the three-batter minimum and pitch clock, Retrosheet/Statcast 2015-2026, versus pre-existing trends and imports' home-league tempo.
Asked on air, for example (paraphrased)How will the pitch clock affect Japan's MLB-caliber pitchers, since Japan's league doesn't use a pitch clock? Trevor, Feb 23, 2026
Ideas that could answer it- Era DialInteractive
Mark the 2023 pitch clock, shift limits and bigger bases, and the 2026 ABS challenges, and show each stat in the seasons before and after.
- Zone ShiftResearch
The called-zone map before and after 2026 is a direct, pitch-level measure of one rule change, the kind of evidence the hosts asked for about every recent rule.
- Era DialInteractive
Q-25How much do divisions and leagues really differ in strength?1 idea7×Queued
Planned studyInterleague and interdivision win percentage, run differential, aggregate projected WAR, lead turnover and division-winner quality, Retrosheet 1969-2026, versus the all-division average and schedule composition.
Asked on air, for example (paraphrased)Why does the AL appear to be the weakest it's ever been this season? guest, Jul 13, 2026
Ideas that could answer it- Division GapResearch
Rank divisions and leagues by their records against everyone outside them, adjusted for opponent quality, so "the toughest division" becomes a number with an uncertainty range.
- Division GapResearch
Q-26Do teams allocate playing time and platoons to their best options?1 idea5×Queued
Planned studyCompare PA and starts by opposing handedness to per-PA production for platooned regulars and bench bats, Statcast 2015-2026, plus pinch-hit penalties and lefty-heavy rotations, versus league usage patterns.
Asked on air, for example (paraphrased)What are the actual stats (batting performance) of good everyday hitters when they are given a day off but then brought in to pinch hit? Trevor, Sep 25, 2026
Ideas that could answer it- Lineup LabInteractive
Swap platoon partners in by pitcher handedness and see the runs added, which shows whether teams are leaving value on the bench.
- Lineup LabInteractive
Q-27Do trades and deadline moves actually add the value expected?1 idea5×Queued
Planned studyIn-season WAR from deadline acquisitions, returns on traded draft picks, cash-inclusive salary dumps and deadline fixes for platoon holes, 2000-2026, versus acquiring-team averages and randomized trade-partner baselines.
Asked on air, for example (paraphrased)When was the last time the Tampa Bay Rays made a surprising in-season trade to bring in a player who actually helped them that year? Trevor, Jul 29, 2026
Ideas that could answer it- Player FactoryResearch
Score deadline acquisitions the same way, over the rest of the season, against what a projection expected, so "the trade worked" means more than one hot month.
- Player FactoryResearch
Q-28What are contracts really worth after deferrals, options and reputation?1 idea5×Queued
Planned studyNet present value of deferred deals at 4-8% discount rates, mutual-option and qualifying-offer exercise rates, and signed-versus-projected value for flagged players, 2010-2026, versus market expectation.
Asked on air, for example (paraphrased)How much real difference does it make to get a shorter, lump-sum contract up front versus a longer deal with deferred money, in terms of present-day value? Trevor, Jan 14, 2026
Ideas that could answer it- Contract X-RayTool
Turn every contract's payment schedule into today's dollars, with deferred money discounted and options and opt-outs valued, so two deals with the same headline can be compared honestly.
- Contract X-RayTool
Q-29Are some players systematically underrated relative to their production?1 idea4×Queued
Planned studyCompare three-year WAR, defensive runs and contact quality to public ranking placement by position, 2015-2026, quantifying ranking-versus-WAR gaps against the league-average ranked player.
Asked on air, for example (paraphrased)Does Michael Harris II have as strong a case as PCA and Ceddanne Rafaela among the top center fielders this year? Jake, Sep 2, 2026
Ideas that could answer it- Contract X-RayTool
Set each player's real contract value against his production to find the players who give their teams the most value per dollar, the ones whose pay and reputation lag behind what they do.
- Contract X-RayTool
Q-30How have strikeout and two-strike contact norms changed by era?1 idea4×Queued
Planned studyLeague strikeout rate, zero-strikeout quality starts, team homers-versus-strikeouts spans and two-strike swing length, bat speed and chase, Retrosheet 1950-2026 and Statcast 2015-2026, versus count-neutral baselines.
Asked on air, for example (paraphrased)Does it mean anything that the Blue Jays have hit more home runs than they've struck out in this series (8 to 7)? guest, Oct 6, 2025
Ideas that could answer it- Era DialInteractive
Draw league strikeout rate and two-strike contact every season, so any comparison between eras starts from what was normal then.
- Era DialInteractive
Q-31How much do starters vary from start to start?1 idea4×Queued
Planned studyGame-score, velocity, release-point and command standard deviation per starter, Statcast 2015-2026, versus league starter variance, with hot-stretch runs benchmarked against each pitcher's own profile.
Asked on air, for example (paraphrased)Did Blake Snell have a season in 2018 where he was similarly dominant/unhittable? Trevor, Oct 7, 2025
Ideas that could answer it- Velo WatchTool
The band itself answers this one. Its width is how much a starter's stuff normally varies from one start to the next.
- Velo WatchTool
Q-32How rare are the spectacular defensive plays we remember?1 idea4×Queued
Planned studyOut probability and frequency per player-game for home run robberies, deep-hole throws and comparable conversions, Statcast 2015-2026, versus positional average play rates.
Asked on air, for example (paraphrased)Has there ever been a game before with three home run robberies by one player? Trevor, Apr 6, 2026
Ideas that could answer it- Glove ConsensusVisualization
Use catch probability to count how many truly unlikely catches happen in a season, so the plays everyone remembers get a sense of scale.
- Glove ConsensusVisualization
Q-33Which early-career signals predict a prospect's future?2 ideas4×Queued
Planned studyCorrelate spring ERA/FIP, debut-month production, promotion age and early homer milestones with subsequent WAR for top prospects, 2000-2026, versus preseason projections as the baseline predictor.
Asked on air, for example (paraphrased)Is the stat about being the 4th player in MLB history with 12+ homers or 31+ RBI in their first 31 career games actually accurate? Trevor, Jul 20, 2026
Ideas that could answer it- Breakout ClockTool
Run the clock on rookies' first months to show which early numbers are already signal, like bat speed and chase rate, and which are still mostly noise, like batting average.
- Prime TimeVisualization
Put young players on the curves to separate skills that are still rising from ones already at their peak, a second angle on which early numbers mean something.
- Breakout ClockTool
Q-34Does defensive positioning and relay choice actually save runs?1 idea3×Queued
Planned studyOut probability and run prevention for infield-in versus back and alternative relay paths, Statcast 2015-2026, by exit velocity, spray angle, runner speed and inning, versus league positioning norms.
Asked on air, for example (paraphrased)If the numbers say playing the infield back in that late-game situation is correct, why don't teams do that all the time? Trevor, Jul 24, 2026
Ideas that could answer it- Spray AtlasTool
Overlay where fielders stood with where each hitter's balls landed, to show which positioning choices took hits away and which left holes.
- Spray AtlasTool
Q-35Does scoring first or playing at home matter beyond talent?3×Answered
Planned studyWin percentage after scoring first and home-team win rate including winner-take-all games, Retrosheet 1903-2025, versus win probability implied by lead, inning and team strength alone.
Asked on air, for example (paraphrased)Read the answerWhy have home teams lost seven of the last eight winner-take-all Game 7s—is it added pressure, or just luck/coincidence? Trevor, Oct 20, 2025
Q-36Is RBI production skill or just opportunity?1 idea3×Queued
Planned studyRBI per baserunner-on-base opportunity versus expected RBI given base states and contact quality, Retrosheet/Statcast 2015-2026, with year-to-year persistence against the league average.
Asked on air, for example (paraphrased)Why does Brandon Lockridge seem to always come through with RBI hits? Jake, May 4, 2026
Ideas that could answer it- Lineup LabInteractive
The simulator counts runners on base for every lineup spot, so it shows how much of an RBI total comes from who bats in front.
- Lineup LabInteractive
Q-37Why does offense shrink in October and in April?1 idea3×Queued
Planned studyDecompose non-homer runs, exit velocity and swing decisions by temperature, date and postseason round, Statcast 2015-2026, into pitcher quality versus hitter approach relative to regular-season baselines.
Asked on air, for example (paraphrased)Is the low-scoring, home-run-only offense in this series due to the style of baseball being played, or because the pitching is so electric that hitters are just trying to connect with one good swing? Jake, Oct 12, 2025
Ideas that could answer it- Power AuditResearch
Split league home runs by month to measure how much of the April and October drop comes from cold weather and the mix of parks, and how much is left for pitching and hitting.
- Power AuditResearch
Q-38Are elite outfield arms disappearing?1 idea2×Queued
Planned studyCount outfielders with 95th-percentile throw velocity plus above-average accuracy, Statcast 2015-2026, versus 1990s baserunner-advance rates from Retrosheet, and within-season arm decline before disclosed injuries.
Asked on air, for example (paraphrased)How many current MLB outfielders have elite, accurate arm strength comparable to historical outfielders like Bernie Williams or Johnny Damon? Jake, Oct 12, 2025
Ideas that could answer it- Glove ConsensusVisualization
Track the league's top arm strengths year by year to see whether elite outfield arms are actually thinning out.
- Glove ConsensusVisualization
Q-39Does the playing surface change batted-ball and baserunning outcomes?1 idea2×Queued
Planned studyGround-ball speed retention, infield hit rate on choppers and sprint-to-first times at turf versus grass parks, Statcast 2015-2026, controlling for batted-ball profile, runner speed and park.
Asked on air, for example (paraphrased)Does the turf at the Trop actually affect player/ball speed in baseball, and if so how? Trevor, Oct 2, 2026
Ideas that could answer it- Spray AtlasTool
Split ground balls by park surface to see whether turf changes how often grounders get through, and where.
- Spray AtlasTool
Q-40What do walks cost, and what causes high walk rates?1 idea2×Queued
Planned studyRun expectancy change from two-out and situational walks, Retrosheet 2000-2025, plus zone, edge and location-variance profiles of high-walk pitchers, Statcast 2015-2026, versus league command averages.
Asked on air, for example (paraphrased)How often does a two-out walk happen in a spot like that, setting up a big moment for the top of the order? Jake, Mar 18, 2026
Ideas that could answer it- Zone ShiftResearch
Track walk and strikeout rates by month alongside the zone's edges. If the edges moved, walk rates should follow, which separates the zone from the pitchers as a cause.
- Zone ShiftResearch
Q-41Where do the on-air milestone and leaderboard claims actually land?1 idea10×Queued
Planned studyRebuild leaderboards from Retrosheet/Baseball-Reference 1871-2026 and Statcast 2015-2026: 9-WAR seasons, catcher offense, DH MVPs, 400/300 club, first-pitch homers, lopsided series, velocity lookups.
Asked on air, for example (paraphrased)Who is the sixth player (along with Beltran, A-Rod, Barry Bonds, Willie Mays, and Andre Dawson) to have both 400 career home runs and 300 career stolen bases? Jake, Jan 21, 2026
Ideas that could answer it- Claim CheckTool
Turn each claim into a query over every team-season or player-season since 1901, then show where the claim really ranks, the near-misses, and the fine print that makes it true or false.
- Claim CheckTool
Q-42What do baserunning decisions and technique cost in wins?1 idea3×Queued
Planned studyWin-probability cost of failing to advance on mishandled balls, slides versus run-throughs, and lane deviation, Statcast tracking 2015-2026, versus league-average advance rates on comparable plays.
Asked on air, for example (paraphrased)How many postseason games have been decided or significantly altered by a baserunner failing to advance because he (correctly) couldn't tell a fielder was having trouble securing the ball, as happened with Durbin and Shaw? Jake, Oct 9, 2025
Ideas that could answer it- Steal LabResearch
Add up the runs gained and lost on the bases, from steals, extra bases taken and outs made running, and turn them into wins for each player and team.
- Steal LabResearch
Q-43How much revenue would a shorter MLB season cost?1×Queued
Planned studyPer-game gate, concession and media revenue from team financial disclosures 2000-2025, modeling eight fewer home-and-away games against attendance and ratings trends and league revenue totals.
Asked on air, for example (paraphrased)What is the actual revenue loss from cutting the MLB season by eight games (from 162 to 154), and would that be offset by producing a better product? Trevor, Jan 14, 2026
Q-44Do the show's draft picks cluster on the same teams?1×Queued
Planned studyCount teams supplying multiple selected position units across prior seasons of the segment, versus expectation if units were independently distributed across 30 clubs.
Asked on air, for example (paraphrased)In past years of this position units draft, how many teams had multiple units (infield, outfield, rotation, bullpen) selected? Jake, Mar 18, 2026